My grandfather was the most important male influence on my early childhood; he was a cooper and my recall of him working in his shed remains vivid. My memories of Derry at the time are of walks by the Faughan where he fished and visits from his brother , Paddy , with his paper bag of Jacob’s fig rolls.
Kenneth Branagh’s engaging movie , ‘Belfast‘, dips into the sensory memory of Buddy, the young film-maker; it is an elegy to a Belfast childhood where family is strong, movies are a great escape but murky, , sinister undercurrents lurk in his neighbourhood. It is essentially a film about the innocence and banality of childhood; the attraction to a smart, wee girl in the class , peer pressure from an older head and the intrigue of religion. Some commentators have been critical of the Branagh version of political history; they are setting up their own cock shots and not the film that was produced. The film-maker set out to create a childhood memory of troubled times and difficult choices and, for the most part, he succeeds in capturing that spirit. The failure of a state to protect its citizens is dramatically portrayed in black and white but quite correctly the underlying issues are not explored; we are seeing events through the eyes of a nine year old.
I was a student in Belfast for four years but was never really part of a local community although with friends I shared a house which had the working class character of that in the film. I visited the City briefly last year and it is clear that many of those areas still exist sixty years on. It is a pity that Branagh didn’t make more use of them as the film leaves an impression of a pristine movie set. The script was well acted although I did question the casting of Judy Dench ; there is a huge number of fine, Irish actors who could have played that minor role more convincingly. The frequency of Pa’s visits home from England seemed in contrast to their economic straits. However, some licence must be granted to the author to progress the narrative and address the old question – Do I stay or leave?.
This generously lyrical interpretation of childhood memory is a welcome addition to films about Belfast.
i found the movie entrancing .I left ireland in the 1970s for new zealand .Came back a few years ago ,love this place .i watched the film for themes ,there was only one …….leaving anything else was peripheral ..now i possibly know more words in maorii that an gaelige
Thanks, Tony. You clearly have a great affection for Belfast ; I suspect that your departure in the 70s had emotional overtones too as emigration does.